So many women tell me that when they ask their doctors and clinicians about them, they are told they are "not licensed", "not approved" or even "dangerous". I understand how worrying and confusing that can be, especially when you have done your homework and simply want to be prescribed the hormone treatments that work best for your body.
Compounded hormone treatments contain the same types of hormones that are in licensed HRT and testosterone. They are made up by a pharmacist in the dose and form that suits each woman. They are not unconventional or unregulated, and for many women they are the type of hormone treatment that finally works well for them.
In this article, I have written about:
• what compounding is, and how long it has been part of medicine
• which other medicines are compounded every day, without any concerns
• how licensed and compounded hormone treatments are regulated
• why the way a hormone treatment is absorbed matters so much
• the other products inside licensed products which may cause side effects and harm
• why having a choice matters, and what to ask your doctor or clinician
What is compounding?
Compounding simply means a pharmacist making a medicine for one person, from its raw ingredients, to a doctor's prescription. For most of history, this is what pharmacy was. The word "apothecary" comes from the Greek word for a storehouse, where the ingredients were kept.
Mass production of drugs by pharmaceutical companies changed this. In the 1930s, around three out of four prescriptions in the US were made up by hand for each patient. By the 1950s it was one in four, and by 1970 about one in a hundred. Now it is far less1.
Factory-made medicines are cheaper and quicker to supply, and they have helped millions of people. But a one-size formulation of a drug does not suit everyone. Some people need a different dose, a different form, or a medicine without an ingredient they react to. This is where compounding pharmacies have important roles.
In the UK, compounded medicines are known as "specials". A pharmacy that makes them must hold a Manufacturer's Specials Licence from the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA), and it is inspected for Good Manufacturing Practice2.
Which medicines are compounded?
Compounding is used in many different areas of medicine, both private and in the NHS. This is well accepted.
Examples of compounded medicines include; chemotherapy for cancer treatments, where the dose is worked out for each individual patient; premature babies needing very low doses of medications; children needing liquid versions of medications; and for people who have allergies or intolerances to medicines containing dyes, fillers or preservatives.
It does not make sense when people refer to compounded hormone treatments as dangerous or risky.
What’s the difference between licensed and compounded hormone treatments?
The structure of progesterone, estradiol and testosterone is the same, whether it is used in a branded patch made by a pharmaceutical company or in a cream made by a compounding pharmacy.
Hormone treatments made by pharmaceutical companies can be synthetic or bioidentical. In the past, HRT was made from synthetic hormones, which are different chemical structures to your own hormones and are associated with risks – including an increased risk of some cancers, clots, strokes and heart attacks, as well as being associated with a greater risk of side effects. These synthetic hormones are still used in contraceptives. Now, in the UK and many other countries, most HRT prescribed contains bioidentical hormones.
The doses of hormones in the hormone treatments made by pharmaceutical companies are fixed so cannot be altered at all, although different strengths are available. For example, there are different strength of patches with different amounts of estradiol in them.
The doses of hormones in the hormone treatments made by compounding pharmacies can be prescribed in an individual way for that patient. For example, if you are not absorbing the estradiol very well through your skin from a patch or gel then using a compounded cream of a different strength may be preferable. This also means that you need to use less volume as the product is more concentrated and if you are paying for your hormone treatments then this can be very cost effective.
Compounded hormone treatments usually only contain the hormone and the base (for example the cream). They do not usually contain additives, colourings or preservatives. They are made up individually for each patient. This means they do not last as long so have a shorter shelf life than hormone treatments made by pharmaceutical companies.
In addition, compounding a hormone treatment can be safer. Currently in UK, US and most other countries, testosterone is not licensed for women so they are usually prescribed male testosterone products. Many of these are hard to dose accurately – for example, trying to divide a sachet of gel into eight equal doses is really hard. Prescribing testosterone as a cream in a pump with a fixed dose in each pump is often much more practical and more accurate.
What does licensed hormones mean?
A licence means a regulator (the MHRA in the UK and FDA in the US) has looked at the trial data for one drug, at one dose, in one group of people. It is an important step, but it does not guarantee that drug is completely safe. Drugs such as Vioxx, Avandia, Zantac and the synthetic estrogen DES were all approved and widely prescribed before being withdrawn or restricted because of harm that was reported following their licence.
These regulators receive income from the pharmaceutical industry through fees. For example, all Marketing Authorisation applicants have to pay a fee.
Compounded pharmacies can vary in products that they make, in one study of products from 13 compounding pharmacies, most were within 10% of the stated dose, but a few were further out3. A good compounding pharmacy will be very transparent about how it tests its products.
Why do women absorb hormone treatments differently?
The same dose of the same hormone is often absorbed very differently in two women. How much reaches your bloodstream depends on how the hormone enters your body, the absorption through your skin if it is a patch or gel, what it is mixed with, and your own skin, gut and metabolism.
Oral hormone treatments, such as micronised progesterone, get metabolised through your liver before reaching the rest of your body. Hormones absorbed through your skin, vagina or rectum avoid this.
However, the absorption of hormones through the skin varies a lot from woman to woman. The cream or gel (base) that the hormone is mixed into is important, some bases carry much more hormone through your skin than an ordinary moisturiser base. Some women simply do not absorb enough from a standard gel or patch, however carefully they use it. Many women tell me that the gel simply floats off their skin or takes ages to dry. These women will not be absorbing as much estradiol or testosterone through their skin as those people who find that they absorb easily.
Hormone treatments made as a pessary or suppository, especially progesterone and estradiol, can be easily absorbed through the mucosa of your vagina or rectum into your blood circulation and are not metabolised in any way.
Very low doses of vaginal hormone treatments can treat vaginal and bladder symptoms, and a pessary or cream can be made in a base that is without additives and preservatives, which many women find preferable to the vaginal hormone treatments that are made from pharmaceutical companies.
Can compounding help progesterone intolerance?
Having choice when prescribing hormone treatments is really important. There are many women who think they have progesterone intolerance but in my clinical experience they often have not find the right preparation for them.
Oral progesterone is poorly absorbed when swallowed, so the powder is "micronised" into tiny particles to help improve absorption. The progesterone is then broken down in your body to other substances, which can lead to side effects. The main side effect is drowsiness, which can be beneficial if you struggle with sleep and take it in the evening. However, some women experience other side effects such as bloating, low mood, and skin changes.
A compounding pharmacy can offer options that licensed products do not, such as a slow-release progesterone capsule that releases the hormone over 8 to 12 hours, or a progesterone cream or pessary that is absorbed into the body simply as progesterone4.
A dose, form and base that suit your body can be the difference between a hormone treatment that works for you and treatment that you give up on.
What else is in your HRT?
Licensed hormone products contain more than the hormone. The extra ingredients, called excipients, are colourings, coatings, oils, fillers and preservatives. They are often labelled "inactive", but inactive only means they are not the medicine. It does not mean they do nothing in your body.
Utrogestan is the licensed oral micronised progesterone used by many women in the UK. Besides progesterone, each capsule contains sunflower oil and soya lecithin, and its shell is made of gelatin, glycerol and titanium dioxide (E171), a white colouring5.
There are different pharmaceutical companies that make micronised progesterone capsules. Every product I have checked contains soya lecithin, gelatin, glycerol and titanium dioxide. The main known difference between them is the carrier oil, for example there is grape seed oil in Gepretix and sunflower oil in Utrogestan. This means that some women will absorb Utrogestan and Gepretix differently.
Also, Utrogestan should not be used by women allergic to soya or peanuts. In the US, the equivalent product, Prometrium, is made with peanut oil and contains synthetic dyes.
If one brand suits you, ask your prescriber to write that brand name on the prescription so the pharmacy does not substitute it for another brand.
Report suspected brand-related reactions through the MHRA Yellow Card scheme. That’s the only route by which these reports become data.
Parabens are preservatives in some vaginal products, such as Blissel gel, its leaflet warns it may cause allergic reactions6. Estriol 0.1% cream in UK contains chlorhexidine, which is an antiseptic preservative that some women are sensitive to. Estradiol 0.01% vaginal cream in US contains sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS), which is a detergent and can be a skin irritant.
Highly concentrated bases in some vaginal products can draw water out of vaginal tissue, leading to more vaginal dryness, which is the opposite of what this treatment is meant to do.
A compounded vaginal preparation can be made without these additives and the hormones are made in a base chosen for sensitive tissue.
Why my view about compounding has changed
My concern with compounding has always been with unregulated clinics, treatments and products where the quality and dose cannot be assured.
What has changed in recent years is my experience and understanding of how prescription compounded hormones can be used. In my Newson Health clinic we work with specialist regulated pharmacies that make the bioidentical hormones treatments for each individual patient according to their personalised prescription, using the same hormone molecules that our bodies produce. This is often helpful for women who cannot tolerate the excipients in licensed products, need a different dose or formulation, or have not absorbed patches or gels well through their skin. Many women also prefer a measured cream, for example with testosterone.
I prescribe compounded hormone treatments selectively, with appropriate clinical assessment, dosing and monitoring, and I do not recommend buying them online or using them without the current medical supervision.
It is not one new study that has changed my view. It is the quality of the pharmacies I work with, together with consulting with many women who have struggled with licensed products and do much better with a personalised option by being prescribed compounded hormone treatments.
In the past, I was taught by that compounded hormones should not be prescribed, and I repeated that advice myself. I trusted this teaching because it came from other colleagues and menopause societies.
The strongest warnings against compounded hormone treatments have come from menopause societies, which actually receive money from companies that make licensed HRT. There is no clear evidence of harm with compounded products when they are prescribed in the right way using an experienced compounding pharmacy.
Some menopause societies and clinicians state that they have concerns about regulation, batch consistency and a lack of trial data. These are relevant and important questions to ask of any pharmacy. Most doctors and clinicians receive almost no training on compounding, so a cautious "no" often comes from unfamiliarity rather than evidence.
I no longer think that the teaching I received about this in the past has been correct and without any conflicts, and it is important that women are able make an informed choice about their hormone treatments.
Summary about compounding hormone treatments
Bodies absorb and metabolise hormone treatments differently, react to different ingredients, and often need different doses at different times of life. Many women find that licensed HRT really suits them, and for them there is no reason to change. But there are some women who only find the right type and dose of hormone treatment that suits them when they are prescribed a compounded hormone treatment.
Choice means being able to choose, with your doctor or clinician, the hormone, dose, route and ingredients that suit your body. Sometimes that is a licensed hormone treatment such as a patch and an oral capsule. Sometimes it is a compounded cream, a slow-release capsule or a preparation free of the additives you want to avoid. For some women it is a mixture of both.
Questions to ask
If you are told that compounded hormone treatments are "not licensed" or "dangerous", you can calmly ask:
1. Do you mean the hormone treatment itself is unsafe, or that this exact preparation has not been through its own trial?
2. Is there a licensed product that matches the dose and form that works for me?
3. What is in the licensed product besides the hormone, and is there an option without titanium dioxide, preservatives or dyes?
4. Does this pharmacy hold an MHRA Specials Licence, and how does it test each batch?



