Menu
My Mission
Articles
Podcast
Events
Workplace Education
Clinician Education
Newson Clinics
Hormones Unlocked
Books
Research
Media
Contact

Balance App
Track symptoms, get insights and feel more in control.
Why are so many doctors still scared of HRT? A medical student explains where that fear comes from and how it spreads.
Toby first saw the problem as a teenager, when his mum, a biology teacher, went to her GP for HRT and was given an outdated FSH test instead. Now in his second year of medical school, he says hormone problems come up on GP placements more than anything else, and the risks of hormone treatment are raised in almost every consultation, often as defensive medicine.
Louise explains why NICE guidance mentions risk far more often than benefit, why grouping synthetic and bioidentical hormones together confuses busy doctors, and why the WHI study still shapes prescribing. They also talk about how hard it is for junior doctors to question a senior, and why a 19-year-old with endometriosis was told pregnancy would fix it.
Toby closes with three take-home tips for changing how every doctor learns about hormones.
Dr Louise Newson: [01:00:00] The podcast today is really interesting. I've got Toby with me who's a medical student, and he talks about his training, about menopause, about hormones, and most importantly, his curiosity to learn more. So enjoy it. So Toby, I'm really excited for this podcast, actually. I'm always excited for my podcasts, but this one I think is going be really special for lots of reasons. You're a young man, you're a medical student, and you know, I am quite jealous because I wish I could be a medical student again for lots reasons. But for one, is that if I had my eyes opened about hormones 32 years ago when I was a medical student, my patients would have had a lot different treatment, I would be a different doctor. So talk to me about you. What year are you in medical school? [01:00:47][47.1]
Toby Wilson: [01:00:47] I've just started my second year. I had an amazing first year, very busy, but all medical students are. And I sort of first came into contact with the menopause and women's health sort of space, probably when I was in year 11. So it was through my mum. So my mum's a biology teacher... [01:01:06][19.3]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:01:07] Okay. [01:01:07][0.0]
Toby Wilson: [01:01:08] ...And she sort of realised she was going through the perimenopause and sort of, by that point I knew I wanted to be a medical student, I wanted be a doctor, so I had that on my radar. And so she was going to the GP trying to get some hormones. She had seen through your work that she needed some HRT and she was nervous about her first appointments. And so I said, don't be nervous, they're doctors, they want to help. They'll listen to you, they'll believe you. This is why they've gone into that career. And she came back and they just didn't offer her hormone replacement therapy. They did that outdated FSH test, which can't be used to predict perimenopause. [01:01:44][36.8]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:01:43] Of course, so that's a blood test that's a waste of time. [01:01:44][0.3]
Toby Wilson: [01:01:48] Exactly. They did all the wrong things and eventually she managed to get her HRT from a really good GP. But I was really interested in the journey and was like, why is this happening to women? [01:01:59][11.7]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:01:59] So did that surprise you, even before you're at medical school, that someone would go and then be refused a treatment? [01:02:04][4.9]
Toby Wilson: [01:02:04] It was so shocking and that's when I looked into things, because I remember saying to her, you don't need to be nervous because they want to help. And it just seemed like they didn't want to help. And so I started looking into it and then the more you look into it, just seemingly the worse it gets and like you can't unsee everything you read. And it just became such a big problem. And I just couldn't believe I hadn't heard about it before. [01:02:29][24.3]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:02:29] And did you notice when your mum did get HRT, did she feel better? Did it make a difference? [01:02:33][3.8]
Toby Wilson: [01:02:35] Oh yes,100%. It's very complex with her because she's got endometriosis as well, so it's a bit of a balancing act. But immediately, I think sleep was a huge thing that she struggled with. Going as a medical student to placements, so many women have trouble with sleep. It's not just like the hot flashes that people typically associate it being. [01:02:55][20.0]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:02:55] No, so after, in your first year, you do, I mean, everything's changed and each university is different, but you do physiology. [01:03:02][6.9]
Toby Wilson: [01:03:04] Yes, so we do like physiology, biomedicine, learning the anatomy of the body and then my medical school is quite clinical so we also learn clinical skills from year one. [01:03:13][9.1]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:03:14] Early on, early on, that's great. [01:03:15][0.8]
Toby Wilson: [01:03:15] So we have clinical skills assessments, which are quite scary, the dreaded OSCEs. [01:03:20][5.1]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:03:21] Yes, I remember those well. [01:03:22][0.3]
Toby Wilson: [01:03:22] But we also have placements scattered around the year in GP surgeries. [01:03:26][3.7]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:03:27] Okay. So that's interesting. So quite early on you're exposed to women. Now all women have hormonal imbalances. So a lot of my work has moved not just, I say 'just' in inverted commas, menopause, but to all women. So women with PMS, premenstrual syndrome, PMDD, endometriosis, PMOS, which was PCOS, mental health, especially after pregnancy when hormone levels shift. Everywhere you look, women have hormonal imbalances so if you're in general practice, presumably you've been seeing women? [01:03:59][32.5]
Toby Wilson: [01:04:00] Yes, I mean, I'd say the majority of the patients that I've actually seen have been women and I don't know if that's just coincidence or just... [01:04:05][5.6]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:04:06] Well no, women go more. I mean, men tend to avoid going to general practice, so women do go more, but so have the GPs and the consultations you've been at, have they been actively talking about hormones? [01:04:18][12.4]
Toby Wilson: [01:04:19] Yes, so I think it's probably, if I was to list all of the patients I've had, I think that's probably the most common thing that comes up. And it's also the most varied thing out of all of consultations I've witnessed and been involved with. They rotate which GPs you are with, so you see a variety of different styles. And some are fantastic, some are less, you know forthcoming with offering HRT. But I think the thing that surprises me the most is how the conversations are shaped. Because some women go in and they know they want HRT, they won't leave without it, which is fantastic because it's really important and often they get it. And I've never actually seen anybody being denied HRT which is good. [01:05:07][48.0]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:05:07] Ok, that's good. [01:05:08][0.2]
Toby Wilson: [01:05:08] Some people have had to work harder than others but I think for the women that are uncertain. They don't know if they should need it or if they don't need it. They've read things online and there's lots of information out there. There's lots different types of HRT. It's that situation where the consultation skills of the doctor are really important in guiding their decision making and making a shared decision. And I think something that I've seen everywhere I've been is the need to talk about the risks of HRT and it's complex because obviously some HRT does have the risks, but the majority of HRT that is prescribed to women has no risks of stroke, blood clots and it's safe. And it says that on the NHS website. So you can look on the NHS website and it says, HRT, that's delivered through the skin, through a gel patch or cream has no risk. But yet it's still something the doctors seem to want to talk about. Some of them it's a click box type thing that they have to check on the system or they just talk about it in general. And nobody said it's a high risk. It's always, it's low risk, but it is a risk. And I think I've sort of challenged a few of them on saying, well, why do you say that? And I the answer I get back is, well, it is defensive medicine. It's their GMC number, their professional registration on the line. And with the increasing litigation, they don't want to face any negative consequences. So they are scared. [01:06:36][88.0]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:06:36] So they're scared aren't they? So, but do you, do you see this when they prescribe other medications, so like antidepressants? [01:06:41][4.9]
Toby Wilson: [01:06:42] No, not at all. So they'll talk about risks, obviously, if there are risks, but there's not, I don't think the need to try and justify the decision and sort of warn people nearly as much. And I think it's just, it's quite a different conversation that happens. [01:06:58][15.8]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:06:58] And what about contraceptives? Do they have the same level of conversation about risks then? [01:07:02][4.2]
Toby Wilson: [01:07:04] Again, some GPs do, some GPS don't. I think it depends on the GP that does it. And some have really educated their patients and give them all of the options so that they can make their own choice, which is fantastic. That's what we want. But then some people just prescribe them and say, read the leaflet, which is, if you open the leaflet, it's huge. [01:07:27][23.2]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:07:27] The leaflet, it's catastrophic because it's not accurate as well, which makes it really confusing. But it is interesting, the whole risk/benefit. And I did a lot of hospital medicine before I went into general practice. And so I was very much about diagnosing a condition, giving the right treatment. I didn't even think about sharing any uncertainty of decision-making with my patients. And then I learned the art of the consultation, which it is an art, everyone is different and they've got different needs, expectations, different ways of talking. And that's where medicine is enjoyable because not every consultation is the same. But it's really interesting because this whole thing where people are so worried about the risks, the risks, the risks, but then if you read the NICE menopause guidelines, I don't know if you've read the updated ones, I actually worked it out. I think this is accurate, but it's close enough. The word risk is mentioned 22 times more than the word benefit throughout NICE guidance. And also the word breast cancer is mentioned in significantly higher numbers than the word osteoporosis. Now, osteoporosis is far more common than breast cancer. And actually, HRT is licensed to prevent osteoporosis. In the NICE guidance, what they did is they grouped together synthetic and bioidentical hormones. So when they talk about HRT, they're not distinguishing between the two. [01:08:56][88.9]
Toby Wilson: [01:08:56] Yeah, they're not making that difference, are they? [01:08:57][1.6]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:08:57] No. And when it was challenged, the key topic advisor for NICE said, oh, well, there weren't any randomised controlled studies for bioidentical hormones, so we just put everything together. But if you're a busy doctor and you don't know, then you are going to think that there are risks. But as you say, the risks are with the synthetic hormones. So that thing is, side of things is confusing. But then I think the other side is that every medicine has risks, but a lot of medicines are far more risky than bioidentical hormone treatments, you know. [01:09:28][30.3]
Toby Wilson: [01:09:28] You're replacing like with like. [01:09:29][1.2]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:09:29] Precisely. So, you know, when we prescribe antidepressants, there's a risk of osteoporosis, there's risk of addictions, there is risk of not having orgasms and reduced libido and no-one is talking about those risks or the anticholinergics are associated with the risk of dementia. No one's talking about that. The bisphosphonates are associated with a risk or atrial fibrillation and heart failure. All these risks are small. But it feels like HRT is the bad guy on the block. It's the one that they focused on. [01:10:04][34.7]
Toby Wilson: [01:10:05] I was, we're doing immunology at the moment. And one of the things we've looked at is vaccines. And of course, there was the big controversy with the MMR vaccine and Andrew Wakefield. And, you know, still now people think vaccines cause autism, even though that study was with 12 people, he, you know, manipulated the results, but it's still in people's minds. And I think that what's happened with HRT is the WHI study, which was flawed in the sense that it was not using the hormones that we use now, but people aren't making that connection and that sort of negative association is still in the back of people's minds and people are just too scared. [01:10:46][41.7]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:10:47] But it surprises me because, you know, medics are clever people, but we're also quite curious. And I think staying curious is really important, whatever you do as your job, but certainly when it comes to medicine and it's evolving. And so now we know, and no-one disagrees, that synthetic hormones are different to the bioidentical hormones, that the WHI was a pretty flawed study. And even if the risks in the WHI with the synthetic were the same with bioidentical say they were, but they're not, the risk is incredibly low and there are benefits. [01:11:20][33.7]
Toby Wilson: [01:11:21] Yeah. [01:11:21][0.0]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:11:22] So it's become so out of context and it feels like, why don't people just stand up and go, look, this is a mistake. We've done things wrong because every day women are harmed because they're not being given a hormone treatment that will improve their future health. And even in the 1970s, people knew that taking hormone treatment reduces osteoporosis, heart disease, dementia. It was in 1948, there was a study showing that osteoporosis is associated with menopause. So it wouldn't take long for them to realise that hormones, even though they were synthetic, they were still having some partial binding on the receptor. So it feels weird that no-one can draw a line through the sand and say, come on guys, let's just move forward. [01:12:10][48.4]
Toby Wilson: [01:12:11] Exactly. And I think there's a difficulty in medicine because you have to be curious to be a doctor. And it's an extraordinarily rigorous process to get into medical school. You've got to go through interviews, you've got have the top grades, you got to do the UCAT exam. There's lots of barriers to get in there. And then when you get there, it's like, great, I've got there. Then you've got your five or six years to become a doctor, and then you've got further training after that to pursue whatever you want to be. But what I think a lot of people don't fully realise is that medicine is unlike most degrees in the sense you don't graduate with a first or a 2:1, it's an unclassified degree. You get a professional qualification out of it. And it's a regulated degree. And so all medical students actually sit the same exit exam at the end called the MLA, the Medical Licensing Assessment. And so medical schools have to train their doctors to be able to sit that exam because that's ultimately what means you can become a doctor. But the time they dedicate to individual topics varies throughout medical schools. And I think a lot of people also don't realise that only a certain amount of the teaching is actually sat in lecture theatres or seminars learning the content with the teacher. Lots of it is picked up on placement. I have placements at the moment, but in the last few years of your degree, almost all of what you do is placement. And so you're learning from the doctors that are there practising. Now some doctors will keep their... [01:13:39][87.2]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:13:38] It really varies, doesn't it? [01:13:40][1.2]
Toby Wilson: [01:13:40] ...You know, knowledge up to date, but, you know there's so much variation and some, you know, won't really have opened a textbook since they graduated. And so until something changes there, or unless you have those doctors that are, you know, moving things forwards, you won't end up changing the education that the medical students are getting because you're training them with, you know, with incorrect knowledge. [01:14:01][20.7]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:14:02] It's really important, isn't it? Because, you know, in medicine, it's always a bit of a joke that you learn something, then you do it and then you teach it, you know... [01:14:14][11.7]
Toby Wilson: [01:14:14] See one, do one, teach one. [01:14:15][1.0]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:14:16] And that's, it is a sort of bit of a joke, but that also, if you're taught the wrong thing, you don't know it's wrong. [01:14:22][6.1]
Toby Wilson: [01:14:22] Yeah. [01:14:22][0.0]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:14:23] And then you teach it wrong and that's what happens. And the other thing that well I mentioned in my theatre tour as well, is that there is this hierarchy in medicine and it's really hard to speak out. So if you don't agree with your consultant, it's a really bad thing and you probably won't get a good reference. So when I was a junior doctor, I chose a doctor who I really, really wanted to work with and he was super lovely, but he thought that every woman who was admitted was depressed. So I would have to write up dothiepin, which is a quite old fashioned tricyclic antidepressant on the notes and it was all handwritten. So we did it on the charts at the end of the patient's bed and we didn't tell the patients. It would go on their take-home medication. Some GPs would have probably carried it on forever. And I often look back at that and think, why didn't I ever ask him, why were they having that drug? What were the risks and side effects? And it really, it really horrifies me actually, because my oldest daughter, you might know, has chronic migraine. And a few years ago, the neurologist in desperation gave her dothiepin to try and help her migraines and it caused memory loss and she couldn't, she was a trombonist, she couldn't play music. She couldn't paint. She, it was like having a child with dementia for a few months and it was related to this drug and it also gave her a horrible tremor and it's not going to do that for everybody. But it is a drug. And I thought, why was I just doing it? I didn't, but I know why, because I was so excited that I got this job. And this consultant otherwise was really whizzy and he was really out there and I wanted to have a good reference from him. I didn't want to upset. And it's really difficult, especially when you are on a ward round, the ward rounds we had, there was a senior house officer, there were a registrar, a senior registrar. There was a nurse, there's a matron. There were seven people around the bed. [01:16:21][118.4]
Toby Wilson: [01:16:22] And plus a few medical students around there as well. [01:16:23][0.9]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:16:23] So then if I suddenly go, sorry, why am I prescribing this? [01:16:27][4.2]
Toby Wilson: [01:16:28] And I think even, it's that whole idea of, on the one hand, you might be getting the wrong information from doctors that haven't updated their knowledge, but we're taught good knowledge and our knowledge that we're taught might be correct, and well, it is correct and it has progressed on from a teaching point of view. But from then putting that into practice, if you're sat there thinking, I think this lady should have some hormones and the GP's saying here are some antidepressants. How can you as a medical student say actually I don't think that's correct? It's so hard to speak out about those things and that's just as a medical student let alone once you've qualified and then you're sort of, the next stage of your career is on the line and it's so tricky and I think there is that patriarchy in medicine that just means it's harder for people to speak out when something's not quite right. [01:17:18][50.9]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:17:21] Thank you for listening today. If you'd like to explore some of the topics I've discussed in more detail, I'd recommend downloading my free Balance app. It's an app that I created to give women easy access to evidence-based information about their hormones and future health. You can track your symptoms, access expert articles, keep a record of your health journey, and connect with a community of women. [01:17:46][24.6]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:17:48] Having some foundation course, like you say, that, that we know that whichever medical school someone's gone to, ideally in the world. So we're not just talking about the UK here, that everybody has, like, if I said to you, I was a GP for 25 years and I never knew anything about asthma or hypertension, see, I mean, you're already laughing, thinking, well, I would never go and see her. [01:18:09][20.5]
Toby Wilson: [01:18:10] That would be ridiculous. [01:18:10][0.3]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:18:10] Yes. But then actually how many patients get asthma and hypertension? How many patients have a hormonal imbalance? Whereas if I said to you or I don't prescribe hormone treatments or HRT, which is what a lot of doctors say. It's like, oh, okay, go and see someone else. [01:18:25][15.3]
Toby Wilson: [01:18:26] You just go along with it. [01:18:26][0.0]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:18:26] It doesn't, like I don't see how it's allowed really, but then going back to the basics, medical students are more inquisitive. They're not quite as sort of burnt out and they've got this thirst thing, you've got younger minds. So it would be great to drip feed in hormones. So you're doing immunology at the minute. My pathology degree was about 20% immunology. And I find the whole cytokines really fascinating. But I also find it's really fascinating how hormones affect immune function. And they have a key role in, you know, making interleukin 6 increase, for example, affecting tumour necrosis factor So, you know, all the different cytokines... [01:19:07][41.4]
Toby Wilson: [01:19:07] And women are far more likely to develop chronic inflammatory conditions. [01:19:11][3.4]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:19:11] Of course they are. Why is that then? [01:19:12][1.3]
Toby Wilson: [01:19:12] Why would that be? Yeah, exactly. [01:19:14][1.4]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:19:14] And has anyone taught you that? [01:19:15][1.4]
Toby Wilson: [01:19:16] Actually they have, which is really good. So we actually did have, you know, they highlighted, you know why might this be, I put up my hand, hormones. And so they are progressing, which is, it's great. But I think ultimately something still needs to be done about, you know, that's from the teaching side of things, but from a treatment side of things. [01:19:38][21.4]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:19:39] Yeah. And that's where, you know, when I set up the course that was Confidence in Menopause. Now we've called it Confidence in Hormones. I really struggled when I, when I had this pivotal shift where I wanted to do more hormone and more individualised hormone treatment, not just prescribe the first thing that was on the BNF, which I'd done for many years. And I thought, well, I need to sit in a clinic. I need to watch someone. I needed to know how to talk to them, what to prescribe, you know the doses and formulations. So I did, I went up to London and I sat in a really great, sadly he's died now, professor of gynaecology's clinic. And then I met him at a conference and I kept quizzing him and quizzing and quizzing him. And it was brilliant. But I thought, actually, it's not easy. It's one-to-one teaching. So that's why I thought well, I'm going do a remote course. And this was way before COVID. I just thought I wanted to make it accessible. So that's why we filmed us doing consultations with people. So you can really get a feel for how to talk to the patient, how to share uncertainty, how to change the dose, and because it is an art as well, it's not just having all the facts in front of you. [01:20:43][64.9]
Toby Wilson: [01:20:42] And every patient's different and you need to be able to adapt your needs to the patient and more and more patients are better educated about their conditions with just the internet but also AI. You can put in your symptoms and it will tell you what you have and it's right quite a lot of the time. And it can then tell you the treatment options. So patients are becoming better informed about their condition. And I think some doctors embrace that, but others are sort of... [01:21:11][28.6]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:21:11] They don't like it, do they? [01:21:12][0.9]
Toby Wilson: [01:21:12] They're put off by the fact they're not the one with the power and the knowledge, and they don't the fact their patients are having the knowledge. [01:21:17][4.9]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:21:17] I think that's really interesting. The word power as well. I don't know about you. I'm sure you're the same. I went into medicine because I wanted to help people, like in a very naive way. I just wanted to help people. [01:21:26][8.7]
Toby Wilson: [01:21:29] No, I know. It's exactly the same, you know, you just want to help people and make a difference. [01:21:32][3.1]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:21:32] Yes, absolutely. But it's not a power thing. I still feel, it's really interesting. I was at an event the other night and someone said to me, are you a real medical doctor? I was like, yes. I thought, like there's nothing special, actually. I don't want to put you down. [01:21:49][17.5]
Toby Wilson: [01:21:50] No, but we're all humans. [01:21:50][0.5]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:21:51] We are all humans and I think it's a gift but it's also a privilege being a doctor and I have worked in some very deprived areas. I have been to houses which have been like, you wouldn't believe how messy, how dirty, how smelly they are. But people tell you things in complete confidence, things that they've not even told their partner or their best friend. And they open up and to have that ability and also you can change the future of your patients. [01:22:20][29.1]
Toby Wilson: [01:22:21] Yes. It's a real privilege. [01:22:21][0.2]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:22:22] It is a privilege, but it's a responsibility. But it should never be abused as a power. There's this fine line. And I also think even with AI, we are not machines. So we are always going to make mistakes. We are always going to get things wrong. And we are always going not always know the answer. And I think with hormones, what happens is people are so scared to prescribe HRT, often for the wrong reasons, as we've mentioned, is that they're really scared to even talk about hormones in the consultation. Whereas I sometimes think, well, you know, if you had a broken leg, I wouldn't be able to fix it for you. But I could diagnose and say, oh, Toby, that looks a bit sore. I think you probably need to go to the hospital. Let me know how you get on. Do you need any painkillers? You wouldn't think I'm a bad doctor because I can't mend your leg. [01:23:09][47.4]
Toby Wilson: [01:23:09] Yeah, exactly. [01:23:10][0.4]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:23:10] And it's the same with this hormone imbalance. When I see young women, I saw someone the other day who's got endometriosis and she's got PMS, so she's struggling with her hormones being low just before her periods. So the consultant said, well, the best thing really to do would be to just go and get pregnant. [01:23:27][16.8]
Toby Wilson: [01:23:28] Well, this is what, so my girlfriend, she's got endometriosis as well. And she has one fantastic GP who was brilliant, did a gynae referral. But then that gynae referral, there's a gatekeeper and she had to have a phone consultation with a different GP. And that GP said to her, most women will get better after they've got pregnant. And so it's so common for people to hear that. [01:23:49][20.8]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:23:49] Isn't it awful though? [01:23:50][0.9]
Toby Wilson: [01:23:50] I can't, why would you say that to a 19-year-old student? [01:23:52][2.2]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:23:53] That's just, and the thing is though, what they're basically saying is you'll feel better when you've got hormones in your body, but they're not joining the dots, you know, so I think this, this is what's got worse. And I don't know whether it's got worse or just people are louder or I'm more accessible to people because in general practice, you're just in your one room and you just see your patients. So I hear stories all the time from women, but they're told it's all in your head. You can't have this, you can't, you know. I spoke to someone yesterday who's had breast cancer, and she's been told she must take an aromatase inhibitor, and she can never have hormone treatments in the future. And she said, I've read, I went on and did the PREDICT score that no-one had told her about before, and she said my absolute benefit from aromatase inhibitors was so little that I've decided I'm going improve my lifestyle, I'm going to stop drinking, I'm go to exercise, I've just decided not to take them. And I might then think about taking hormone treatments for the future, And she said, when I said to the consultant, I'm happy with that decision, he was a bit confused because it wasn't his decision. But I think as doctors, we have to be flexible and listen to our patients, don't we? [01:25:03][70.1]
Toby Wilson: [01:25:04] I think it needs to start from the bottom up. I think change needs to be made, not even just at medical school because that is getting better, but it needs to be changed for everybody at secondary school. I distinctively remember in my science lessons at school being taught that testosterone is the main male reproductive hormone, estrogens are the main female reproductive hormone, which is factually correct, but it's... [01:25:30][25.6]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:25:31] Missing out a lot... [01:25:31][0.1]
Toby Wilson: [01:25:31] You know, it's such a simplification that it ends up being misleading and people think testosterone is boys, estrogen is girls, whereas actually, we all have them. They just do different things. And it needs to change from that point onwards. And, you know, you get taught about puberty, adolescence, the menstrual cycle, pregnancy, what would the logical next step be? Menopause. No, the curriculum stops before then. And so my mum's a biology teacher and so she's now teaching her classes, you know. It doesn't stop here, this is just the start of it, but there's the other side of it as well. And I think people need to be empowered because the current doctors that we have, it would take a lot of effort to really change them. But if you can move through, throughout time, things will get better. And we are already seeing that, but the patients can initiate that because if they're more empowered and they've got the knowledge, then it's hard to disagree. [01:26:24][52.9]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:26:24] And that is what's happening. And I do think we're in a bit of a pivotal time because people, a lot of people like my work, but some people really don't like it. And they don't know the way that I'm giving people information. And then they don't like the way that women are asking for hormone treatments. And I think it's great actually. But if you're trained really well, you're not going to be only thinking about hormone treatments, you're going to thinking very holistically about everything else as well and make sure there's no other condition. But it's giving people the right confidence as well, to have that conversation with their patients. But it's also joining the dots in a very simple way. And that's my book, The Power of Hormones. I've written a lot about how hormones work in the body. So not how hormone treatments work, how hormones work. And I don't know if you saw an Instagram post my daughter did when she realised that testosterone builds the myelin sheath. [01:27:22][57.6]
Toby Wilson: [01:27:23] Yes, yes, I know, I saw that. [01:27:24][1.1]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:27:24] Yes. And it's really interesting because she worked it out herself and the myelin sheath for those listening who don't know, basically is like the conducting system around nerves and it helps the nerves to fire very quickly. [01:27:33][9.3]
Toby Wilson: [01:27:33] It means they can travel really quickly instead of really slowly. [01:27:36][2.9]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:27:35] Absolutely. Yes, and so for people with multiple sclerosis, often the myelin sheath degenerates and degrades. [01:27:40][5.1]
Toby Wilson: [01:27:40] Yes. [01:27:40][0.0]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:27:41] So testosterone especially, but also estradiol and progesterone help build the myelin sheath, restore it and keep it working really well. And so we've got data showing that men with low testosterone are more likely to have multiple sclerosis. So my patients with multiple sclerosis, I make sure that all three hormones are really well balanced and it makes such an amazing difference to their symptoms. But when she joined the dots and said this, it was very interesting because there was no pushback on social media, everyone was really interested, whereas if she said, treatment with testosterone helps build the myelin sheath. I can't imagine what would have been out there. But that's where like having the basics at school, in undergraduate, postgraduate, then it becomes a second nature. A bit like learning about the metabolic effects of insulin and glucose. It's just another hormone really then, isn't it? [01:28:32][51.4]
Toby Wilson: [01:28:33] Exactly. And I think that is so important that you look at what the actual hormones do in the body because it goes so much beyond just the reproductive side of things. And I think what not everybody realises is just how important they are. You know, estrogen acts in the brain, it acts on bones. That's why women get osteoporosis after the menopause. And so people need to start joining up those dots more and actually considering everything as a whole, because a lot of medicine is holistic medicine. Think of the person as a whole. But then when it comes to individual things, you can go very narrowly down one path and actually forget the bigger picture. [01:29:12][39.4]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:29:13] And that's really important because, you know, even now, a lot of my patients who are very stable in the clinic, the GPs say, Oh, you've got to see the menopause specialist. You've got go to the gynaecologist and I'm like, hang on this person's had a hysterectomy. She's had her ovaries removed. She's got no reproductive organs. [01:29:29][16.3]
Toby Wilson: [01:29:30] No pelvic organs... [01:29:30][0.4]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:29:30] Why does she need to see a gynaecologist? You know, if I was a gynaecologist, I would be saying, no, actually, it's not a gynoecological problem. It's a multi-system disorder that every doctor should know about. So it doesn't make sense because, you know, if I had type 1 diabetes, which is a pancreas problem, I wouldn't go and see a pancreatic surgeon. [01:29:50][19.7]
Toby Wilson: [01:29:51] No, you would go and see your GP. And the thing is, so many women's health conditions are quite common. Endometriosis, that affects one in 10 women, which is very similar to type 2 diabetes, affects roughly 10% of people. But the treatment isn't the same in terms of, you know, how long does it take to get a diagnosis. That could be nine years for some people with endometriosis. Well, I think that's the average. It's awful. [01:30:15][24.2]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:30:15] I think it is, and then actually getting treatment is a completely different... and then the treatment that they get is often quite not right. So there's so much, there needs to be so much, a different style and different priority, and I often think about, let's think about the health of women rather than women's health, because if you talk about women's health, it's immediately goes straight back to... [01:30:36][21.4]
Toby Wilson: [01:30:36] Yeah, people just assume, don't they. [01:30:38][2.2]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:30:38] Yes. So we've got loads to do, but you're already thinking. So whatever you do in the future Toby, you are going to help women, which is fantastic. And men because obviously thinking about male hormones is also good. So three take home tips. If you were in charge of medical education for all medical students, what three things would you want to instigate now so that people would be educated about hormones? [01:31:04][25.7]
Toby Wilson: [01:31:04] Well, I think firstly, start early. So have the knowledge before you actually need it. Because if you build those foundations, then that's the big problem, isn't it. You've got to have the foundations before you can do anything. So start that education early. Start it year one of medical school, even before then. Give it to the general public. Make sure you educate everybody from aged 16. I think secondly, this is more sort of for the patients, but and doctors as well, but they should know what's normal. I think too many things are normalised, especially in women's health or the health of women. So many things are normalised when they're actually not normal and we can do things about that. So everybody should know, what's normal and when things should start to become a problem. But I think the third point, which is probably something I've lived my whole life by and if you ask my teachers back at school, they'd probably say, Toby was one that asked questions, but I think be curious and ask questions. Never stop thinking, why, why does this happen? My teachers are probably already going, oh, not another question, Toby. It's what you have to do. Just never be afraid to ask those questions. [01:32:15][71.0]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:32:16] Yes, and I hope that stays with you because staying curious gets you into a bit of trouble, but it's also really good to keep your mind and help more patients at the end of the day. So thank you so much for coming. [01:32:27][11.6]
Toby Wilson: [01:32:28] Well, thank you for having me. [01:32:29][0.9]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:32:29] Thank you. [01:32:29][0.3]
Dr Louise Newson: [01:32:32] So just a quick one, it would be really great if you could follow or subscribe to this podcast. This will really help me reach more people with evidence-based information about hormones and their future health. And it also ensures that you'll never miss a future episode. Thank you. [01:32:32]