Podcast
120
Why don’t most psychiatrists prescribe hormone treatments for women with postnatal depression?
Duration:
26.38
Thursday, November 19, 2026
Available on:
HRT/Hormones
Education

Postnatal depression follows a sudden drop in estradiol and progesterone after birth, yet hormone treatments are rarely offered during this time.

Jennie Milnes knows this first-hand. She had postnatal depression after her first son, and in her early 40s, while switching her HRT for perimenopause symptoms, she found out she was pregnant again. After her daughter’s birth the hormone crash was even worse, and despite being on HRT before her pregnancy, she was told to wait for her hormones to settle.

Dr Louise Newson explains why postnatal depression is more likely the second time, why antidepressants work better alongside estradiol, why hormones are safe while breastfeeding, and why so few psychiatrists prescribe them. She also shares the history of Dr Katharina Dalton, who used progesterone to support fertility and pregnancy.

Dr Louise Newson: [00:00:02] So today on my podcast, I've got Jennie with me, who's going to be very open about her story, which I think will resonate with more people than even she realises, because we don't talk enough about postnatal mental health and just about changes of hormones that are not recognised and feeling alone and dismissed. So I'm very grateful that you're here, Jennie today, because you reached out to me with your story and I'd be really grateful if you could just talk a little bit about what's happened to you over the years. [00:00:32][29.6]

Jennie Milnes: [00:00:33] Yes, so, I am currently now 47, if I think about it. When I was 35, I had my first son, Thomas. We did have some fertility issues having Thomas, so we did go to the fertility clinic. We were going through fertility testing, the usual things that you have to go through to kind of tick off what's, you know, right and what's not. I was then put on Clomid, which I had three rounds of and we were lucky enough on the third cycle of that, that I conceived with Thomas. So that was just over 11 years ago now. After I had Thomas, it was quite clear to my close family that, you know, there was something not quite right going on and I didn't really feel like myself. And it was kind of decided after going to the doctor that, you know, it was postnatal depression. I do have a history of depression and anxiety in the family, so it wasn't kind of a massive shock. So I went to see the doctor openly was like, you know, I need help, whatever you can suggest to help me be in a better situation and be a better mum for my baby, that is what I need to do. So I kind of got put on fluoxetine, which was the... [00:02:12][99.0]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:02:13] So it's an antidepressant, isn't it. [00:02:14][1.7]

Jennie Milnes: [00:02:15] Yes, and more for anxiety, I guess. I know it's given to people that have got OCD and things like that. Six months passed, I wasn't really told much about the actual medication. I started to feel better in myself, I think maybe just through getting out, doing things, just being a bit more confident in myself. So I actually just came off the medication, which looking back now, I should have been on for at least six months before anything happened and I shouldn't have just come off it without any advice. Fast track forward, then probably four or five years and I think just the experience of the postnatal depression, I didn't have a good experience at the birth. I was dead against having any other children. I thought, you know, this is it. I am like, I do have a sibling. I was very aware of, you know, having a sibling would be a positive thing, but I was like, no, I can't go through this again. And I just kind of put it to the back of my mind. And then of course, like, further down the line, you kind of start to want what you think you can't have. And I start having regrets about, you know, maybe not thinking about having a child sooner because obviously, at this point, I was like, early 40s and, you know the time is ticking. And fast track again, I suppose, another couple of years, maybe a year or two, I was looking at kind of information about perimenopause because it was massive at the time, like with yourself, the Balance app, the Davina McCall books, myself and my friend, we went through it, we brought the book together, we discussed things, and actually we were like I think this is kind of going on for us, so maybe we just need to do something about it. So went to the doctors with all the information that I'd collected, literally printed out and went to a doctor who told me I probably knew more about my symptoms than she did and was quite open about that, but was quite happy to, you know, if you to try it that's fine if you you look like you know you've done your research kind of thing. So I was then put on HRT. So I was on the gel and I was on the Mirena coil. The Mirena coil was great, but I, I just didn't feel myself with it. I don't know, I can only describe it as just feeling a bit dead. Like flat, dead, just not myself and it wasn't a nice feeling to be like that. I remember thinking like one Christmas, you know, I should be full of joy and happiness. I've got my family around me, but I just really didn't feel any of that. I just totally had to kind of fake it. So I thought, well, maybe that's just, well, optimistically, I thought maybe it will change, but it never did. So I went back to the doctor and said, I don't think this is working for me and she offered an alternative. By this point, I had done more research and thought about the kind of body identical hormones. I knew a little bit more about that so I was telling her, you know, I think you do have a sensitivity, especially to the progesterone and could I look for something that was probably going to be a little more suited to me? So I didn't have such a different reaction to it or possibly. So she changed that to the Utrogestan. [00:06:38][262.9]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:06:39] Utrogestan, so did you have the Mirena coil taken out? [00:06:42][2.5]

Jennie Milnes: [00:06:42] I did. So I'd had two and the first time I had the Mirena coil, I felt the same thing. The second time I thought, oh, maybe it was just, you know, maybe it'd be different this time, but no, it wasn't. [00:06:58][15.4]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:06:59] And did you feel better after it had been taken out? [00:07:01][2.4]

Jennie Milnes: [00:07:02] I did. Like literally it was like kind of, I wouldn't say an instant thing, but quite a quick thing. I mean a lot of people, you're just offered that. That's the first thing that you are offered. I understand why. So she was quite happy to do that. She was like, yeah, let's give it a try. She was, I was quite lucky that I had a doctor that was willing to like kind of listen to what I was saying really. So obviously there was like a crossover between the Mirena coil coming out and then me taking the progesterone. [00:07:36][34.0]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:07:37] The progesterone, yes. [00:07:38][1.0]

Jennie Milnes: [00:07:38] And we didn't, I'd never kind of wanted to close the door totally on having another child. So I didn't take contraception. I wanted to basically just not have anything in my system for once, just to see actually what I was like without any hormones, anything extra if you know what I mean. So my libido came back from holiday just for a short time. It'd been off around the world, travelling for a while. So in between obviously changing my HRT, things happened and when I looked to take the Utrogestan and it said well before you take it for the first time you need to make sure you know that you're definitely not going to be pregnant and I was like well there's no chance of that, well actually, oh I don't know well I'll just do it in case and I don't know what I was thinking really I don't know if I thought there might have been a tiny slim chance but I did a pregnancy test and it was like positive and I was like, I mean. I don't know what I felt in that moment, but I really was quite happy. It was a positive thing for myself. My husband may have had a slightly different reaction, but for me, it was like, wow. I mean, I didn't know like, how this had happened. Obviously I later found out that, you know, when you're given HRT and it kind of boosts your body and makes it kind in the best condition it could be for pregnancy. Well, if I'd have known that I might have taken it a bit earlier. [00:09:29][111.1]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:09:31] Well, this is the thing, because it's topping up your own hormones, a lot of people find their fertility improves when they're taking the right dose of hormone treatment. And so many people think hormone treatment is in contraception, which it isn't. And even the Mirena coil contains a synthetic progestogen which blocks the action of progesterone in the body. So, you know, for you that have had fertility problems before. It's interesting that no one had thought about giving you just some natural hormones to boost your fertility then. [00:10:00][29.9]

Jennie Milnes: [00:10:02] No, and I do think like, wow, if that happened to me, is that something that could happen to other people? I mean, as in like a positive thing, could that be something that women could take. [00:10:11][9.0]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:10:11] Well, people used to, yes, in the past, we know that, I mean, our hormone progesterone was actually, once it was first discovered, people knew that it helped maintain a pregnancy, but also helped prepare the womb as well for pregnancy. And so many, many years ago, it was given a lot. There's a doctor called Katharina Dalton, who I've spoken about in the podcast before, and she used to give a lot of progesterone to women, but also knowing that it improved fertility. But then at the same time she was working, the synthetic contraceptives came to market and everyone tried to silence her. And people have forgotten sometimes about very simple ways of trying to improve the bodily functions. So that's why the Mirena is a contraception because it's not a bioidentical hormone, but the estradiol and also progesterone are and they are safe to be taken for the first three months of pregnancy to help as well. So then you were pregnant and then did you feel well when you were pregnant? [00:11:13][62.6]

Jennie Milnes: [00:11:14] When I had my son Thomas, I didn't have any side effects. I wasn't ill or anything. This time was different and I was like, oh, maybe this is a girl because I was so, so sick from I think probably about week 8 to 13. So really I'm probably quite lucky because some people really do get it a lot worse than that, but it was bad. But after that, yes fine, I had a great pregnancy, really good. I really enjoyed it and just made the most of it. Lots of going out for cups of tea and decaf coffee and afternoon teas and cake. [00:12:03][49.0]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:12:04] And then what happened after the baby was born? [00:12:07][3.9]

Jennie Milnes: [00:12:08] Well, that was not a great experience. Again, I actually changed hospitals this time because I had not a great experience last time, so I changed the hospital thinking It might change. So anyway, we won't talk much about that, but it wasn't a great experience. So when I had her, I lost a lot of blood, I think I lost about a litre of blood. Had to have like an iron transfusion and all sorts. It was just a bit of a mess. But she was fine and I was good. And then we came home and I think it just, I just had this massive, I can only describe it as like this hormone crash. I had read about like postnatal depression, but this was worse. I don't know if it was like, I was aware, made aware of like kind of psychosis, is it, that you can get? I think it wasn't on the severe end, but it certainly was worse than what had happened before. I think my body just didn't know what it was doing. [00:13:23][75.3]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:13:24] And that can sometimes happen because you're a bit older as well, so your baseline hormones won't be there. Sometimes people's, the rapid decline of hormones can occur a bit quicker. And anyone that's had any postnatal mental health disorder, whether it's postnatal depression, postnatal psychosis, is more likely to have it the second time. But did anyone warn you that it might happen again? [00:13:47][23.5]

Jennie Milnes: [00:13:49] No, I kind of was obviously aware of it myself. And this time, I guess as an older mum, I was trying to do everything in my power to make sure that I was like prepared. So I had, I did hypnobirthing. I did lots of reading. I did lot of like online, you know, videos I did midwife chat things. I did, I had a doula. I mean like you know for positivity and all that. I had all sorts of things because I knew and also before I'd had this chat with a lady about, what did she call it now, it was to do with post-traumatic therapy but like birth trauma therapy I think that's what she said. So I had done all these kind of things. [00:14:41][52.2]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:14:41] So you tried everything? [00:14:42][0.4]

Jennie Milnes: [00:14:42] Oh I did everything. I did everything! [00:14:44][1.7]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:14:45] So this time when it happened, did you go back on antidepressants or what treatment were you given? [00:14:50][5.4]

Jennie Milnes: [00:14:52] So the midwife, I can't remember lots I just remember at one point that I was just, and what hit home for me was when I came to see your tour in Leeds. [00:15:05][13.0]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:15:05] Yes. [00:15:05][0.0]

Jennie Milnes: [00:15:06] And the young man that came on and spoke about his mum. [00:15:09][3.4]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:15:09] Jay, yes. [00:15:10][0.8]

Jennie Milnes: [00:15:10] Yeah. And I remember, I remember what hit home with me was like, when he spoke about how his mum was just like curled up in a ball and she just wasn't, you know, it wasn't his mum. And I just remember like being curled on the sofa. I couldn't, I just was not, I just couldn't function. I was, you're trying to breastfeed. You're not sleeping. Then with the hormones all over the place or lack of. It just, the midwife kept coming in and she's like, I'm really quite worried. I was like going, I know I just, I wasn't eating, I wasn't really drinking, I really wasn't really doing anything. I didn't have energy. I just couldn't do anything. And she, I actually was telling her about like this obviously, the HRT and thing and she was like really quite amazed and shocked. And she was like going, Oh, I don't know. I don't know maybe you should go back on it. And I was like, going, I don't know, should I go back on it? And then I went to see the doctor because she was like, I think you need to go back to the doctor and see and doctor was like, well, your hormones are all over the place. Obviously, like with just having a baby, they need to really settle so that we can just give it a bit of time. [00:16:33][82.5]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:16:33] So your doctor didn't suggest going back on to the hormone treatments? [00:16:39][5.7]

Jennie Milnes: [00:16:40] She didn't suggest going back on it straight away. And I don't know. I can't really remember if it was me going like, well, I need something. I need something. So they gave me the Fluoxetine again, because I said I'd had that previously. And it did actually, it did make a difference so that I could start, it wasn't like, obviously it takes a while doesn't it? It can take a month or, you know, to get kind of into your system. So it wasn't a quick thing. So for the first kind of couple of months was just a nightmare really. It was just like, just trying to survive each, each day. But I had, thankfully, a lot of good friends and family and basically like one of my friends would just come round and just walk me around the back garden so that I'd go out because I just couldn't, I just didn't want to do anything. [00:17:39][58.7]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:17:41] So how did you improve eventually? [00:17:42][0.9]

Jennie Milnes: [00:17:44] I think it was just a mixture of like the, obviously the Fluoxetine, my friends, family, people coming and helping me and supporting me. And I don't know, it just gradually got better because obviously I wasn't back on the HRT straight away. So God knows really how I managed to survive that. But I did. [00:18:09][25.1]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:18:12] Thankfully. [00:18:12][0.0]

Jennie Milnes: [00:18:12] And then, well, you just do, don't you? You've just got to do it, you've just go to do. I've got like my son to look after as well, your priority is not yourself, is it? It's everybody else. And so then, then I did go back on the HRT again. I can't really remember exactly when that was and I've been back on like the patches and you know, the progesterone since then, really, but I've been on the same dose. And I've being kind of quite level, I would say, but then the last probably few months things have kind of seemed to have shifted and symptoms and things are flaring up big time. [00:18:59][46.7]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:19:00] Yes, and as we said before we recorded, you're on a fairly low dose of estradiol, you take progesterone but you're not on any testosterone either and so you're now in your 40s, your level will be lower than it was 20 years ago. So we're going to help you to rebalance your hormones and hopefully you will improve even more. But it's really sad for me as a clinician, knowing what I know and knowing that what we've known for decades about this big hormonal imbalance that occurs when people give birth and you know there's 850,000 women a year have postnatal depression in the UK alone. So there's millions of women every year that are suffering and for some women they have psychosis, some women have to obviously go into hospital and every person is really looked after by a psychiatrist. And psychiatrists don't usually have training in hormone treatments and very few of them prescribe hormone treatments, yet they know there's a hormonal imbalance. And when people are older, like we were saying, you don't have quite the same level of background hormones often. But younger people can still get postnatal mental health disorders. So it sort of beggars belief really why doctors aren't thinking about giving those hormones and I've prescribed hormones for many years, and for some women who have postnatal depression, we give those hormones and then when their bodies start to have their own hormones coming back up and they're having regular periods, they don't always need to take them forever, especially when they're younger, but as we're seeing more older people who are having babies and then their hormones are less likely to bounce back, what we are realising is that some women do need, like you probably do, a slightly different dose of hormones to rebalance them and the hormones are very safe, they're very safe when people are breastfeeding as well, yet there seems to be this big reserve and resistance to prescribe them and they're a lot safer than antidepressants and they can be given with antidepresants, so if you needed the Fluoxetine then it doesn't mean you can't have it, but we've known for many years actually that SSRIs, which are the type of antidepressant that Fluoxetine is one of. They work better in the presence of estradiol because those hormones work really well on our brain and they will help the connections in the brain as well. So it's very sad that people are still struggling. [00:21:32][151.8]

Jennie Milnes: [00:21:33] Yes, I mean, you just don't know where to, you don't know where, what path to go down to get help. I mean I was really lucky that, actually this time around, I was referred to a perinatal team, Southwest Yorkshire Trust, which wasn't available when I had Thomas, it's only been around for five years, but this team consisted of like, psychotherapists, doctors, nursery nurses, people that could help you with like your, the feeding, people who could help with parenting skills. And this probably was one of the big things that actually helped me because there was this team available with all these different specialists but specifically to help people that were suffering from any kind of postnatal mental illness and things. So I was really, really lucky that I had that support. [00:22:46][72.4]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:22:46] Which is great, but they still didn't prescribe your hormones. [00:22:49][3.0]

Jennie Milnes: [00:22:50] No they didn't, no they didn't. [00:22:51][1.0]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:22:52] I think their jobs would be a lot more rewarding if they saw, and the thing is in medicine you don't know until you see the results in your patients, and if you never give a treatment you'll never see the response, so you know, hoping with time and more education doctors will, and other clinicians will become more confident in prescribing hormone treatments. [00:23:13][21.0]

Jennie Milnes: [00:23:14] Oh it must be so frustrating for you when you think it's just so obvious. [00:23:18][4.0]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:23:20] It is so obvious but I think that's where this podcast is really important because I think others who will listen will hopefully, I mean hopefully they won't have your experience but if they do or they know others, they can help advocate because I think it's come to the time where people should be asking and saying, well, I would like to try a hormone treatment. Could you measure, we don't really measure progesterone levels but we can measure estradiol and testosterone levels and say, please, can I try it. I spoke to someone yesterday who was doing some volunteering work in mother and baby units and she said one woman has been there for nearly a year and they've tried so many different medical treatments a bit like Hayley, Jay's mum, had and was diagnosed as treatment resistant but nobody had given her hormones. So we have to be thinking differently to try and help more women really. So you sharing your story has been really important for others hopefully to hear. So I'd really like to end by just asking you three take-home tips. So if people are listening to this podcast and they think, that's me, that's my daughter, that my friend who's suffering, what three things do you think they could do to to try and help them so that maybe they can access some hormone treatments? [00:24:37][76.9]

Jennie Milnes: [00:24:39] I think knowledge is power. It is just being aware of who you can speak to and don't take no for an answer. You've got to really, unfortunately, fight for things. I was lucky that I had people that were positive and proactive on my side, but I wasn't going to take no for answer. [00:25:09][29.8]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:25:10] Yes. [00:25:10][0.0]

Jennie Milnes: [00:25:11] Whereas some people aren't quite as strong as that or don't have the support to do that. So if you've got like people around you or you know somebody that you think might be, just make sure, just make them aware that you are there for them to help them when they need it. Because you don't always want to kind of reach out, but you want, in the end, you do need that. You do need support and help. And just read, just like, you know, like I did, I went online and looked for myself and did research and like your information, your books, your app, the information on there and you've just got to find it and go and say, look, right, I need something, I need you to do something, I need you to help me. [00:26:04][53.5]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:26:06] Absolutely. [00:26:06][0.0]

Jennie Milnes: [00:26:07] If you don't do it, no-one else is going to do it for you. [00:26:09][2.4]

Dr Louise Newson: [00:26:10] Yes, that's so important, really good advice. And really go and see someone else if you don't get the right help the first time, it's absolutely fine to do that. And so I'm very grateful, and I look forward to seeing how you are when your hormones are properly balanced, but even what you're having is still better than not taking anything at all, that's definitely for sure. So thank you so much for your time today Jennie, it's been great. [00:26:33][23.1]

Jennie Milnes: [00:26:34] Oh, thank you. [00:26:34]

‍

Subscribe

* indicates required